Credo
Spirit
Sense
of
Life
Objectivists Headquarters
War
People
Store
Forum



Forum
Archives
Objectivism

Post to this threadMark all messages in this thread as readMark all messages in this thread as unread


Post 0

Monday, June 27 - 9:15pmSanction this postReply
Link
Edit
Wonderful, wonderful review!

Rachmaninoff has always been my favorite, and his incomparable 3rd Piano Concerto my favorite piece of music. Ever. (In fact, my new bride and I knew we had some soul connection when we discovered that we both felt the same way about it.) The Rhapsody is my second favorite of his work, too: it is the most lighthearted piece of music I know, and like some angel dancing on a cloud, its unforgettable melodies defy all gravity.

Your thoughts about how these might be the inspiration for "Halley's 5th" in Atlas Shrugged are notions I've shared since I was a 19-year-old kid, and was listening to the 3rd Concerto while reading the novel for the first time. The novel and the 3rd are inextricably linked now in my subconscious, and I can't hear those glorious, soaring themes without thinking of scenes and characters from the novel. There's a glorious piano passage in the third movement that sounds like a continuing burst of laughter, with the glittering piano runs tumbling over a hint of minor-key melancholy in the string section, and for the life of me, every time I hear it I can see Francisco d'Anconia.

Thanks for a magnificent review. And please come back here and post frequently.



Post 1

Monday, June 27 - 9:44pmSanction this postReply
Link
Edit
P. S. The most awesome interpretation of the 3rd I've ever heard is Alexis Weissenberg playing with George Pretre and the Chicago Symphony. The recording is from the late 60s, I think, and nothing I've heard before or since even comes close -- not even that of Volodos or Rachmaninoff himself! It's the one that most evokes the scenes of Atlas for me.





Post 2

Monday, June 27 - 11:23pmSanction this postReply
Link
Edit
Katherine - I'm mortified to think that Rach wasn't listed here. Rest assured there's been much adulation heaped upon him on SOLO over the years, & I am an unabashed worshipper (even have a T-shirt! :-)). I have numerous versions of his major works, & many minor ones, but not the Weissenberg Rach 3 that Robert mentions. My attempts to locate it thus far have been unsuccessful. Having just acquired Weissenberg's Rach 2 & Tchaik 1, I can believe that his Rach 3 is as good as Robert says it is. In any event, thanks so much for the review. Rach rocks. :-)

Linz



Post 3

Tuesday, June 28 - 1:07pmSanction this postReply
Link
Edit
Is it too much of a sin to mention that the 1975 song "All by Myself" by Eric Carmen was based on the music of Rach 2 Adagio?

I actually knew the music to the song, before hearing the concerto. But imagine my delight upon discovering the original.

Also, Rhapsody on a Theme By Paganini is a wonderful piece. 

Again I admit to first becoming acquainted with the famous parts of this piece through Julian Lloyd Webber and elsewhere.  Ah, pop culture :-)

Thanks for this posting this :-)

 




Sanction: 4, No Sanction: 0
Sanction: 4, No Sanction: 0
Post 4

Monday, October 24 - 9:03pmSanction this postReply
Link
Edit
Marcus Bachler wrote:
Is it too much of a sin to mention that the 1975 song "All by Myself" by Eric Carmen was based on the music of Rach 2 Adagio?
No more so than to mention that a popular song from the mid-20th century, "Full Moon and Empty Arms," was based on the Rach 2 Finale!  :-)
Also, Rhapsody on a Theme By Paganini is a wonderful piece.
Yup, but it's Rhapsody on a Theme ~of~ Paganini. Also, while we're mentioning sinful spin-offs, the lovely 18th variation in this piece was used as the theme for a coffee (Folgers?) commercial back in the 70s (or was it the 60s?). Imagine that!

Roger Bissell, Post-Randian musician-writer




Post to this thread
User ID Password or create a free account.