Credo
Spirit
Sense
of
Life
Objectivists Headquarters
War
People
Store
Forum



Forum
Archives
Objectivism

Post to this threadMark all messages in this thread as readMark all messages in this thread as unread


Post 0

Friday, September 6, 2002 - 7:02amSanction this postReply
Link
Edit
I have to keep this short, as I'm running the compiler, so all I'm going to say is "right on!"

I do disagree with your statement that human beings are born stupid. It sounds pedantic, but all people are born ignorant, only some are born stupid. After all, ignorance can be remedied by education. Reality itself deals with stupidity, as evidenced by the Darwin Awards. >^..^<



Post 1

Sunday, September 15, 2002 - 3:09amSanction this postReply
Link
Edit
When my son was a little boy he always wanted to grow up to be a scientist, so he could "discover a cure for death" so his Mom would never die. Sweet, but I have been "dead" many times in my loooong life. I call those times the black cloud of depression. Those are my static times. I always eventually come back into the sunshine and start living life again. My dynamic times. You are so right when you say life is in the living of it. I do believe though, that most people go one way or the other depending on their immediate situation. In other words, they have no choice. Yes, they can go forward and work to become dynamic again but in the meantime it's really dark in that "black cloud". (And you usually don't know your're in it till you come out the other side.) They just make themselves as comfortable as possible, and I think sometimes, fear keeps them stuck in the dark. These are your static people.



Post 2

Monday, September 16, 2002 - 11:46amSanction this postReply
Link
Edit
I think the answer to the question, "What is the meaning of life?" becomes crystal clear when it's rephrased to say "What is the meaning of your life?"



Post 3

Tuesday, March 22 - 2:08pmSanction this postReply
Link
Edit
The first is the goal. In the static view of life, you aim to avoid death. It upholds a negative as your source of values. It's all a struggle against death, which you'll eventually lose. When many people think this through, they ask questions like "what's the point of it all? I'm going to die anyway, aren't I?"

In the dynamic view of life you aim to live your life and enjoy the process of living it. Your goal isn't to prevent death, except in that death prevents you from continuing to live. You aim at the positive. The static view just can't be made to match the dynamic view. Even if you try to include elements of the dynamic view, such as your ability to grow as a person, or your mental habits you've developed, the ends are just too different. If given an opportunity to abandon all action for certain security, the static view would take it, and the dynamic view wouldn't. An example is a technological marvel that puts you on a respirator, feeds your body all the nutrients it wants, but doesn't allow you to physically act. Yes, your body would still live on. But that's not life!
To me, this was the most important point of the article. I wish I would have read this part first.



Post 4

Thursday, May 26 - 1:37pmSanction this postReply
Link
Edit
I work as a physician and deal with life and death on a regular basis. If life is defined as the ability to perform executive functions and not as cardiopulmonary activity, it has huge ethical ramifications.

Philosophically, I prefer the dynamic definition of life. I hope to continually learn, achieve and grow.

Medically, I wouldn't be justified in pulling the plug on someone who is alive according to your static definition.

Overall, this is a thought provoking look at how we define life.





Post 5

Thursday, May 26 - 7:31pmSanction this postReply
Link
Edit
Thanks Dean, to further refine your refinement:

An example is a technological marvel that puts you on a respirator, feeds your body all the nutrients it wants, but doesn't allow you to physically act. Yes, your body would still live on. But that's not life!
This reminds me of the wonderful quote about ships (paraphrased):

A ship is safe while docked in harbor--but that (harbor) is not what ships are for.

Ed




Sanction: 3, No Sanction: 0
Sanction: 3, No Sanction: 0
Post 6

Tuesday, September 13 - 5:23pmSanction this postReply
Link
Edit
Joe; after an article like this, the only words coming out of my mouth are "THANK YOU"

Happiness is also when you are able to appreciate the good in others.





Post to this thread
User ID Password or create a free account.